Australian Superannuation Trap – To Invest In or Out of Super?

The roots of the Australian superannuation system stretch back to the early 20th century. With the public sector pioneering the introduction of pension schemes for employees during that time.

Essentially, the concept of superannuation revolves around providing financial support to individuals during their retirement years. However, the modern system as we understand it today only took shape in the late 1980s.

The notion of Compulsory Superannuation emerged in the 1980s, crystallizing into the Superannuation Guarantee (SG) in 1992. The primary objective was straightforward: to incentivize Australians to save for their retirement and alleviate the strain on the government’s age pension system.

The SG mandated employers to contribute a percentage of their employees’ earnings to a superannuation fund. Starting at 3% in 1992, this contribution rate has progressively increased to 11% at the moment. Further increments are planned, with the rate expected to reach 12% by 2025.

Australia’s superannuation journey has transformed from its early pension schemes into a comprehensive and compulsory system, dedicated to ensuring the financial security of retirees.

Engaging in superannuation investments brings forth several tax benefits. Contributions made from pre-tax income, known as concessional contributions, enjoy a lower tax rate of 15%, generally below an individual’s marginal income tax rate.

Yet, there’s a subtle trap lurking in the realm of superannuation. As the future remains uncertain, the perceived tax haven within super may not be as enticing as one might believe.

Australian Superannuation Risk

Let me be clear; I’m not opposed to Australian Superannuation. In fact, I consider it a remarkable tool for compounding wealth. Especially given its nature as a sort of enforced savings that remains untouchable until you hit the preservation age.

Yet, there’s a catch. Those who depend on their superannuation for retirement might be in for a letdown due to shifts in legislation. A kind of sovereign risk in the investment realm.

If we think about it logically, the government’s budget may fall short for the age-pension system in the future. Payments down the road could be considerably less than what they are today.

The aging population and increasing life expectancy are major challenges for the age-pension system. The government might tweak eligibility criteria or adjust contribution rates and tax policies, but that’s not exactly a politically expedient move. This is precisely why superannuation came into play.

Just as the government can alter legislation to suit its needs, there’s a looming risk of changes to superannuation arrangements. From the outset, the idea behind superannuation was to motivate Australians to save for retirement. Lightening the load on the government’s age-pension system.

During the pandemic, the government allowed Australians to dip into their super balances, up to $20,000. If that amount were to compound for another 30 years at a nominal 8.5% yearly return, the balance would soar to $231,000. Adjusting for inflation, it would sit around $127,000.

Regrettably, over 2.6 million Australians cleared their balances at the pandemic’s peak, totaling a staggering $38 billion. Astonishingly, a significant chunk was spent on gambling, department stores, and takeaway meals.

Quite a twist for what’s supposed to be a retirement account, isn’t it?

Australian Superannuation and Its Flaws

The current preservation age in Australia ranges from 55 to 60 years old. Essentially, during this period, the government permits withdrawals from your Australian Superannuation fund.

However, under the latest Superannuation Act, there’s an anticipation that this age will transition from 55 to 60. In practical terms, it implies that access to your superannuation funds will only be granted after reaching the age of 60—extending the waiting period by 5 years.

In such a scenario, relying on superannuation for retirement funding becomes less favorable. Options include prolonging your working years, utilizing personal savings outside of super (if available), or resorting to the age pension until superannuation access is granted.

Compounding the situation, the Age Pension eligibility age is set to increase from 65 to 67 years, potentially leading to disappointment.

If you perceive superannuation as a tax haven, future developments might not be so favourable. Similar to how wealthy individuals exploited company trust structures in the past, distributing income to children and even pets to minimize tax obligations.

This prompted the government to close the loophole, imposing high tax rates on individuals under 18 years old. Where taxes are 66% on distributed amounts between $417-$1307, or 45% of the entire amount above $1307.

More recently, changes dictate that superannuation balances exceeding $3 million will face a 30% tax instead of the previous 15%. If you believe your money is secure within these structures, it’s essential to reconsider. Government might introduce new rules.

Nevertheless, Australian Superannuation remains a currently more tax-effective space for compounding retirement funds. Just be mindful that this landscape may evolve, particularly if you’re still in the early stages of your career.

Early Retirement And Your Superannuation

If you derive satisfaction from your work and don’t mind continuing until your later years, the sovereign risk associated with Australian Superannuation may not pose a concern.

While some individuals find contentment in working until retirement, I don’t share that sentiment. The notion of dedicating two-thirds of life to work, only to spend the remaining third in old age and frailty, doesn’t appeal to me.

So, the pivotal question is whether to invest within or outside our Australian Superannuation account.

Given the notably low savings rate in developed Western countries, standing at 3.4% for Australia, the superannuation scheme emerges as a commendable idea.

However, for those with the ability to take charge of their finances, investing outside of super may yield greater benefits. This isn’t to disregard the valuable tax benefits that superannuation offers.

Finding the right balance that aligns with your goals is crucial, and seeking professional advice is advisable if uncertainty lingers. Despite salary sacrificing my income to my superannuation and matching my employer’s contribution, I choose to invest and save the majority of my income outside of superannuation.

This decision stems from an awareness that legislation regarding retirement age and superannuation access may likely change. My personal goal is to have the choice not to work in my mid-40s, and the path to achieving this involves investing outside of super.

This strategy ensures cash flow and capital liquidity for a comfortable lifestyle before accessing my superannuation fund.

My perspective is that, if all goes according to plan, I won’t need to touch my superannuation funds. While I don’t require it, the funds can continue to compound indefinitely. It’s worth noting, however, that after a certain age, a minimum amount, known as the “minimum pension drawdown,” must be withdrawn.

Key Takeaways

• The Australian Superannuation, a powerful tool for wealth compounding, poses risks with potential legislative changes. Aging population challenges may strain the age-pension system, making prudent financial planning essential.
• While superannuation is a great investment vehicle for retirement funds, you never know what the government has plans for the future. They very well may raid that purse for their own benefits like we saw in early 2022
• Having an investment portfolio and savings buffer as opposed to only superannuation will give you better financial flexibility.

Incognito Wealth – Investing Tools

Need help with investing in the stock market or personal finance? Visit my Etsy store for digital excel templates. Simplifying finance so that everybody can reach financial independence.

Incognito Wealth - Financial Independence One Investment at a Time